vinylfanatics.com

**16 Horsepower - Secret South**
★★★★☆

In the grand tradition of American music's most compelling outliers, David Eugene Edwards has always operated in the shadows between salvation and damnation, crafting hymns for the spiritually restless with the fervor of a backwoods preacher and the soul of a punk rock iconoclast. With Secret South, 16 Horsepower's fourth and what would prove to be final studio album, Edwards delivered perhaps his most cohesive statement on the eternal struggle between flesh and spirit, wrapped in the kind of gothic Americana that makes Nick Cave's Bad Seeds sound like choirboys.

Following the raw intensity of 2002's Folklore, Edwards retreated deeper into his Denver stronghold, emerging three years later with an album that felt like a fever dream broadcast from some forgotten corner of the Bible Belt. The intervening years had seen the alt-country movement reach its commercial peak and inevitable backlash, but 16 Horsepower remained gloriously immune to such earthly concerns, operating in their own parallel universe where murder ballads and religious ecstasy coexisted in perfect, terrifying harmony.

Secret South finds Edwards and his conspirators—multi-instrumentalist Jean-Yves Tola and the rhythm section of Pascal Humbert and Bertrand Cantat—mining the darkest veins of American musical tradition. This is gothic country in its purest form, where banjos become instruments of menace and Edwards' distinctive vocal style—part Johnny Cash, part Tom Waits, with a healthy dose of evangelical fervor—transforms simple folk melodies into apocalyptic proclamations.

The album's opening salvo, "Horse Head Fiddle," immediately establishes the record's unsettling atmosphere. Built around a hypnotic banjo figure and Edwards' most unhinged vocal performance, it's a masterclass in controlled chaos that recalls the band's punk origins while pushing deeper into folk territory. The song's circular structure mirrors its protagonist's mental state, creating a sense of claustrophobic inevitability that permeates the entire album.

"Splinters" stands as perhaps the album's finest moment, a deceptively simple ballad that showcases Edwards' gift for finding the sacred in the profane. Over gentle acoustic strumming and mournful violin, he spins a tale of spiritual fragmentation that feels both deeply personal and universally resonant. It's the kind of song that haunts you long after the needle lifts, a testament to the power of Edwards' singular vision.

The title track serves as the album's dark heart, a sprawling meditation on America's original sins that finds Edwards at his most prophetic. Driven by a relentless rhythm and punctuated by moments of startling beauty, it's both a love letter to and indictment of the American South, acknowledging its musical and cultural contributions while refusing to ignore its troubled history.

Throughout Secret South, Edwards demonstrates his mastery of dynamics, knowing exactly when to pull back and when to unleash hell. "Cinder Alley" builds from a whispered confession to a full-throated roar, while "Beyond the Pale" finds beauty in restraint, its delicate arrangement serving as the perfect vehicle for Edwards' most vulnerable vocal performance.

The album's production, handled by Edwards himself along with Bob Ferbrache, captures the band's live intensity while allowing space for the subtle details that make repeated listening so rewarding. The sound is deliberately raw, eschewing modern polish in favor of an organic warmth that makes every creak and breath feel intentional.

Secret South would prove to be 16 Horsepower's swan song, as Edwards dissolved the band shortly after its release to focus on his new project, Wovenhand. In retrospect, it feels like the perfect conclusion to the 16 Horsepower story—a band that always operated on its own terms, creating music that was simultaneously ancient and modern, sacred and profane.

The album's legacy has only grown in the years since its release, influencing a generation of artists who recognize Edwards as one of America's most uncompromising musical voices. In an era of manufactured authenticity, Secret South stands as a reminder of what genuine artistic vision sounds like—unsettling, uncompromising, and utterly essential. It's an album that demands complete surrender, offering in return a glimpse into the soul of American music's dark underbelly.