Wish You Were Here

by Badfinger

Badfinger - Wish You Were Here

Ratings

Music: ★★★☆☆ (3.5/5)

Sound: ☆☆☆☆☆ (0.0/5)

Review

**Badfinger - Wish You Were Here: A Bittersweet Swan Song**

In the pantheon of rock's greatest tragedies, few stories cut as deep as Badfinger's meteoric rise and catastrophic fall. Their 1974 album "Wish You Were Here" stands as both a creative triumph and a haunting epitaph for a band that should have conquered the world but instead became casualties of the music industry's darkest machinations.

To understand the weight of "Wish You Were Here," you need to trace Badfinger's journey through their three defining albums. It began with 1970's "No Dice," where these Welsh lads, originally called The Iveys, emerged as Apple Records' most promising signings after The Beatles themselves. With Paul McCartney producing their breakthrough hit "Come and Get It," the album showcased their gift for pristine pop melodies wrapped in muscular rock arrangements. Pete Ham's songwriting prowess was already evident on tracks like "No Matter What," while the band's four-part harmonies rivaled anything coming out of Laurel Canyon.

Two years later, "Straight Up" cemented their reputation as masters of power pop before the term even existed. Produced by George Harrison and Todd Rundgren, the album spawned the immortal "Day After Day," featuring Harrison's distinctive slide guitar, and the achingly beautiful "Baby Blue," which would later find new life as the closing song to "Breaking Bad." The record perfectly balanced Ham's introspective ballads with Tom Evans' more driving rockers, creating a template that countless bands would follow.

But it's "Wish You Were Here" where Badfinger's artistry reached its peak, even as their world crumbled around them. By 1974, the band was trapped in a web of managerial corruption and label disputes that would ultimately destroy them. Warner Brothers had signed them away from Apple, but their manager Stan Polley's shady dealings left them virtually penniless despite their commercial success. Recording under this crushing pressure, the band channeled their frustration and desperation into their most cohesive and emotionally resonant work.

The album opens with "Just a Chance," a driving rocker that belies the turmoil behind the scenes, Ham's vocals soaring over Joey Molland's jangly guitars with an urgency that feels prophetic. The title track, written by Ham, serves as the album's emotional centerpiece – a gorgeous, melancholy meditation on loss and longing that ranks among the finest ballads of the decade. When Ham sings "I wish you were here with me now," there's a vulnerability that cuts straight to the bone.

"Meanwhile Back at the Ranch" showcases the band's heavier side, with Mike Gibbins' thunderous drumming and a guitar riff that anticipates the arena rock to come. It's followed by "Love Is Easy," perhaps the album's most underrated gem, where Evans' bass work anchors a deceptively simple melody that reveals new layers with each listen. The song's breezy surface masks lyrics about emotional manipulation that feel uncomfortably relevant given the band's circumstances.

"Dennis," Ham's tribute to Beach Boys drummer Dennis Wilson, captures the sun-soaked California sound the band admired, complete with layered harmonies and a melody that sticks like honey. But it's "In the Meantime" and "Love Time" where the album's true genius lies – two songs that find hope amid despair, with production that's both lush and intimate.

Tragically, "Wish You Were Here" would be Badfinger's final statement as a cohesive unit. Legal battles with Polley prevented the band from touring or recording, leading to Ham's suicide in 1975 and Evans' similar fate eight years later. The music industry had chewed up and spat out one of its most talented acts.

Today, "Wish You Were Here" stands as a masterpiece of power pop, its influence heard in everyone from Cheap Trick to Wilco. The album's blend of Beatles-esque melody, Who-like power, and distinctly American production created a sound that was both timeless and ahead of its time. Streaming services and reissue campaigns have introduced new generations to Badfinger's catalog, with "Wish You Were Here" increasingly recognized as their creative peak.

In an alternate universe, this album launched Badfinger into stadium-headlining superstardom. In ours, it remains a bittersweet reminder of talent destroyed by greed – a beautiful

Login to add to your collection and write a review.

User reviews

  • No user reviews yet.