vinylfanatics.com

**Band of Horses - Infinite Arms: The Sound of Growing Pains**

There's something beautifully bittersweet about watching a band evolve, especially when that evolution feels like watching your favorite indie darlings slowly shed their scrappy underdog status for something more polished, more accessible, and inevitably more divisive. Band of Horses' third studio album, "Infinite Arms," released in 2010, represents exactly this kind of crossroads moment – a record that finds Ben Bridwell and company caught between their raw, emotional past and a more commercially viable future.

To understand "Infinite Arms," you need to trace the band's journey through their holy trinity of early releases. 2006's "Everything All the Time" burst onto the indie scene like a perfectly timed lightning strike, all reverb-drenched guitars and Bridwell's falsetto soaring over Neil Young-inspired soundscapes. Songs like "The Funeral" became instant classics, the kind of tracks that soundtracked countless late-night drives and early morning heartbreaks. It was scrappy, immediate, and utterly captivating.

Two years later, "Cease to Begin" refined their formula without losing the magic. The production was cleaner, the songwriting more focused, but tracks like "Is There a Ghost" and "The General Specific" proved that Band of Horses could evolve without sacrificing their emotional core. The album felt like a natural progression, building on their strengths while expanding their sonic palette.

Which brings us to "Infinite Arms," an album born from significant upheaval. Following the departure of founding members Mat Brooke and Rob Hampton, Bridwell relocated from Seattle back to his native South Carolina, bringing with him a collection of songs that would become their most personal and, paradoxically, most universally appealing work. The geographical shift is palpable throughout the record – gone are the Pacific Northwest's misty, ethereal atmospherics, replaced by something warmer, more grounded, and decidedly Southern.

Musically, "Infinite Arms" finds the band embracing a more straightforward rock approach while retaining their gift for sweeping, cinematic arrangements. The production, courtesy of Phil Ek, is their cleanest yet, sometimes to the album's detriment. While tracks like the opening "Factory" showcase their ability to craft immediate, radio-friendly anthems without completely abandoning their indie credibility, there are moments where the polish threatens to smooth away the rough edges that made their earlier work so compelling.

The album's standout tracks reveal a band grappling with maturity and change. "Laredo" is perhaps their most affecting ballad, a gorgeous meditation on distance and longing that builds from whispered intimacy to soaring catharsis. "Blue Beard" channels their earlier, more experimental tendencies into a hypnotic groove that feels both familiar and fresh. Meanwhile, "Compliments" serves as the album's emotional centerpiece, a tender love song that showcases Bridwell's growth as both a vocalist and lyricist.

However, it's the title track that best encapsulates the album's themes and contradictions. "Infinite Arms" is simultaneously their most accessible and most emotionally complex song, a sweeping anthem about commitment and vulnerability that works equally well blasting from car speakers or whispered through headphones at 3 AM. It's the sound of a band learning to balance their artistic instincts with broader appeal, and mostly succeeding.

Not every moment hits with the same impact. Songs like "On My Way Back Home" and "For Annabelle" feel slightly undercooked compared to the album's peaks, lacking the emotional urgency that made their previous work so essential. The cleaner production occasionally works against them, making some tracks feel a bit too safe, too calculated.

Yet "Infinite Arms" succeeds as both a snapshot of a band in transition and a collection of genuinely affecting songs. It marked their commercial breakthrough, reaching number seven on the Billboard 200 and spawning several radio hits. More importantly, it proved that Band of Horses could evolve without completely losing their identity.

Looking back over a decade later, "Infinite Arms" occupies a unique position in their catalog. While it may lack the raw immediacy of "Everything All the Time" or the focused intensity of "Cease to Begin," it captures a specific moment of growth and change that feels increasingly poignant. It's the sound of a band learning to embrace both their limitations and their possibilities, creating something that's undeniably them while reaching toward something bigger. In the end, that tension between intimacy