vinylfanatics.com

Cage the Elephant's third studio outing finds the Kentucky quintet wrestling with the weight of expectation and emerging bloodied but triumphant. Following the commercial breakthrough of 2010's *Thank You Happy Birthday*, the band faced that most perilous of sophomore album syndromes – except this was their third go-round, making the stakes even higher.

The album's genesis can be traced to a period of intense creative restlessness for frontman Matt Shultz and his cohorts. After extensive touring behind their self-titled debut and its follow-up *Thank You Happy Birthday*, the band found themselves creatively scattered, dealing with the pressures of major label expectations and the challenge of defining their sound beyond the garage rock revivalism that had initially made their name. The recording sessions, helmed by producer Jay Joyce, became a crucible for experimentation, with the band deliberately pushing against their established formula.

What emerges is a fascinating document of a group in transition, caught between their punk-influenced roots and a more expansive, psychedelic-tinged vision. The musical palette here is considerably broader than their previous efforts, incorporating elements of alternative rock, post-punk, and even touches of electronic manipulation that suggest a band unafraid to colour outside the lines. Shultz's vocals remain the central attraction – a rubber-band instrument capable of manic yelps, crooning vulnerability, and everything in between.

The album opens with "Always Something," a deceptively gentle acoustic number that quickly morphs into something more unsettling, establishing the record's theme of surfaces concealing darker truths. It's a clever bit of misdirection that prepares the listener for the shape-shifting journey ahead. The real statement of intent comes with "Shake Me Down," arguably the album's masterpiece and certainly its most emotionally resonant moment. Built around a hypnotic guitar figure and Shultz's most restrained vocal performance, it's a meditation on mortality and regret that finds the band operating in an entirely different register. The song's gradual build and release demonstrates a newfound maturity in their songcraft.

"Aberdeen" serves as the album's most direct link to their earlier work, a propulsive rocker that showcases their ability to craft arena-ready anthems without sacrificing their essential weirdness. Shultz's vocal acrobatics are on full display here, switching between conversational verses and soaring choruses with the kind of ease that suggests natural talent rather than studied technique. The track's success lies in its ability to sound both familiar and surprising, a neat trick that the band pulls off repeatedly throughout the record.

Perhaps the most adventurous moment comes with "Rubber Ball," a paranoid slice of post-punk that finds the band exploring darker sonic territories. The rhythm section of Jared Champion and Daniel Tichenor provides a locked-in foundation that allows guitarists Lincoln Parish and Brad Shultz to explore more textural approaches to their instruments. It's a song that rewards close listening, revealing new details with each encounter.

The album's production deserves particular praise for its ability to capture the band's live energy while allowing space for their more experimental impulses. Joyce's work here strikes an ideal balance between clarity and grit, ensuring that even the album's quieter moments retain a sense of tension and unpredictability.

*Thank You Happy Birthday* represents a crucial pivot point in Cage the Elephant's evolution, demonstrating their ability to grow beyond their initial garage rock template without losing the essential spark that made them compelling in the first place. The album's commercial success – it peaked at number two on the Billboard 200 – proved that audiences were willing to follow the band into more adventurous territory.

In the years since its release, the album has come to be regarded as the moment when Cage the Elephant truly found their voice. Songs like "Shake Me Down" have become staples of alternative rock radio, while the album's more experimental moments pointed the way toward their later, even more adventurous work. It stands as a testament to the rewards of artistic risk-taking, a reminder that the most interesting music often emerges from periods of creative uncertainty. For a band that could have easily coasted on their established formula, *Thank You Happy Birthday* represents a bold leap into the unknown – and a successful landing on the other side.