vinylfanatics.com

**Cake - Prolonging The Magic**
★★★★☆

In the late Nineties, when nu-metal was flexing its muscles and Britpop was nursing its post-Oasis hangover, along came Sacramento's most unlikely quintet with their third album, a gloriously perverse collection that proved alternative rock didn't have to scream to be subversive. *Prolonging The Magic* arrived in October 1998 like a deadpan comedian at a heavy metal festival – completely out of place, utterly confident, and somehow stealing the show.

Cake had already established their singular aesthetic with 1996's *Fashion Nugget*, but *Prolonging The Magic* saw John McCrea and company refining their recipe of ironic detachment, minimalist arrangements, and that distinctive trumpet courtesy of Vince DiFiore. Following the unexpected success of "The Distance," the band faced the classic sophomore album pressure – how do you follow up a freak hit without betraying everything that made you special in the first place?

Their answer was to double down on the deadpan. McCrea's vocals remain resolutely anti-virtuosic, delivered with the emotional range of a particularly world-weary DMV clerk. It's a style that shouldn't work, yet somehow transforms mundane observations about modern life into something approaching profundity. Over skeletal arrangements built around Greg Brown's economical guitar work and Todd Roper's metronomic drumming, Cake created a sound that was simultaneously lazy and urgent, detached yet deeply engaged with the absurdities of American life.

The album's masterstroke is "Never There," a relationship autopsy delivered with such studied indifference that it becomes genuinely affecting. McCrea's flat delivery of lines like "You're never there, you're never there, you're never ever ever ever there" transforms what could have been maudlin into something genuinely moving. The song's success – reaching number one on the Modern Rock charts – proved that audiences were hungry for alternatives to the prevailing angst-rock orthodoxy.

Equally brilliant is "Let Me Go," where Cake's minimalist approach reaches its apotheosis. Built around a hypnotic guitar figure and punctuated by DiFiore's mournful trumpet, it's a meditation on romantic claustrophobia that feels both deeply personal and universally relatable. The way McCrea delivers "When she walks away from me, I feel like I can't breathe" with all the passion of someone reading a grocery list somehow makes the sentiment more, not less, powerful.

The album's political consciousness emerges most clearly on "Alpha Beta Parking Lot," a seemingly simple tale of suburban ennui that gradually reveals itself as a savage indictment of consumer culture. Over a groove that wouldn't sound out of place on a Seventies funk record, McCrea observes the rituals of modern American life with the detached fascination of an anthropologist studying an alien civilization.

"Sheep Go to Heaven" finds the band at their most playfully subversive, wrapping existential questions in a deceptively bouncy arrangement. The song's central metaphor – contrasting the supposed destinations of sheep and goats in the afterlife – becomes a meditation on conformity and rebellion that's both profound and utterly ridiculous.

The album's production, handled by the band themselves, maintains the deliberately lo-fi aesthetic that had become their calling card. Every element sits exactly where it needs to be in the mix, creating space for each instrument to breathe while maintaining the overall sense of controlled restraint that defines Cake's sound.

*Prolonging The Magic* stands as perhaps the definitive statement of late-Nineties alternative rock's more cerebral wing. While their contemporaries were either wallowing in grunge's dying embers or embracing the emerging aggression of nu-metal, Cake carved out a completely unique space that owed as much to talking heads and minimalist art as it did to rock tradition.

Twenty-five years later, the album's influence can be heard in countless indie acts who've adopted Cake's template of ironic detachment and musical minimalism. Yet none have quite captured the specific alchemy that made this record so compelling – that perfect balance between sincerity and distance, between engagement and ennui.

In an era of increasingly maximalist production and emotional exhibitionism, *Prolonging The Magic* feels almost revolutionary in its restraint. It remains a masterclass in how less can indeed be more, and how sometimes the most profound statements come wrapped in the most unassuming packages.