vinylfanatics.com

**Fall Out Boy - Infinity On High**
★★★★☆

In the winter of 2007, Fall Out Boy stood at a crossroads that would have terrified lesser bands. Fresh off the massive success of "From Under the Cork Tree," which had transformed them from Chicago basement heroes into MTV darlings, Pete Wentz, Patrick Stump, Joe Trohman, and Andy Hurley faced the dreaded question: how do you follow up perfection? Their answer came in the form of "Infinity On High," an audacious leap that saw the quartet trading their safety net for a trapeze act, complete with orchestras, gospel choirs, and enough ambition to power a small city.

The album's genesis was anything but smooth. Wentz's highly publicized struggles with depression and a suicide attempt in 2005 cast a shadow over the band's meteoric rise. Meanwhile, the pressure to replicate their previous success weighed heavily on all four members. Rather than retreating into familiar territory, Fall Out Boy decided to blow up their own playbook entirely. Working with producer Neal Avron, they crafted an album that felt less like a collection of songs and more like a cinematic experience – one that borrowed equally from Broadway, classic rock, and the pop-punk blueprint they'd helped establish.

Musically, "Infinity On High" represents Fall Out Boy at their most adventurous and, arguably, their most polarizing. The band's signature emo-pop foundation remains intact, but it's been dressed up in increasingly elaborate arrangements that sometimes threaten to overshadow the songs themselves. Stump's vocals have never sounded more confident or theatrical, swooping from tender crooning to full-throated belting with the ease of a seasoned showman. His voice carries the album's emotional weight while Wentz's lyrics dive deeper into themes of fame, mortality, and the peculiar isolation that comes with success.

The album's opening salvo, "Thriller," sets the tone with its swaggering confidence and Jay-Z guest verse – a collaboration that raised eyebrows but ultimately proved inspired. It's a mission statement wrapped in a three-minute pop song, announcing Fall Out Boy's intention to transcend genre boundaries. "The Take Over, the Breaks Over" follows with one of their most infectious hooks, driven by Trohman's razor-sharp guitar work and a chorus that lodges itself in your brain like a friendly parasite.

But it's "This Ain't a Scene, It's an Arms Race" that serves as the album's crown jewel and most divisive moment. Built around a piano riff that wouldn't sound out of place in a Vegas lounge act, the song is simultaneously Fall Out Boy's biggest hit and their most radical departure. Wentz's lyrics skewer the very scene that made them famous while the band delivers one of the most undeniable hooks of the 2000s. Love it or hate it, it's impossible to ignore.

"Thnks fr th Mmrs" continues the experimentation with a gospel-influenced arrangement that transforms a song about fleeting relationships into something approaching spiritual catharsis. The track showcases the band's growing sophistication while maintaining the emotional directness that made them stars. Meanwhile, deeper cuts like "Golden" and "Fame < Infamy" reveal a band grappling with the costs of success, delivered with the kind of melodic sophistication that separates great bands from merely popular ones.

The album isn't without its missteps. Some tracks feel weighed down by their own ambitions, and occasionally the orchestral flourishes feel more like window dressing than integral elements. But these are the growing pains of a band refusing to play it safe, and they're easily forgiven in the context of such bold artistic leaps.

Fifteen years later, "Infinity On High" stands as Fall Out Boy's most fascinating document – a snapshot of a band at the peak of their powers and popularity, unafraid to alienate fans in service of artistic growth. While it may lack the raw urgency of their earlier work or the streamlined focus of their later albums, it captures something equally valuable: the sound of a band refusing to be boxed in by expectations.

The album's legacy is complicated but undeniable. It proved that pop-punk could accommodate orchestras and opera singers, that emo could flirt with hip-hop, and that success didn't have to mean creative stagnation. "Infinity On High" remains Fall Out Boy's most ambitious statement, a glorious mess of ideas that somehow coheres into something greater than the sum of its parts.