vinylfanatics.com

**Fear Fun**
*Father John Misty*
★★★★☆

The transformation of Joshua Tillman from Fleet Foxes' bearded drummer into the silk-shirted, wine-soaked prophet known as Father John Misty reads like a biblical parable for the indie rock generation. After years of keeping time behind Robin Pecknold's pastoral harmonies, Tillman experienced what he's described as a mushroom-fuelled epiphany in Big Sur, emerging from the Californian wilderness with a new persona that would prove to be one of the most compelling reinventions in recent memory.

*Fear Fun*, his 2012 debut under the Father John Misty moniker, arrived like a Trojan horse wheeled into the gates of earnest indie folk. On the surface, it appeared to be another singer-songwriter album, complete with lush orchestrations and confessional lyrics. But lurking within was something far more subversive: a masterclass in irony, self-awareness, and the kind of literary songwriting that hadn't been heard since the heyday of Randy Newman or early Leonard Cohen.

The album's sonic palette draws heavily from the golden age of Laurel Canyon, with Tillman and producer Jonathan Wilson crafting arrangements that nod to Harry Nilsson's orchestral pop, the Kinks' theatrical vignettes, and the baroque flourishes of *Pet Sounds*-era Brian Wilson. Yet beneath these familiar textures lies something distinctly modern – a neurotic energy that reflects our age of digital overstimulation and existential drift.

Opening track "Funtimes in Babylon" sets the tone with its swirling strings and Tillman's crooning declaration that he's "writing from the epicenter of my discontent." It's a mission statement wrapped in a love song, introducing us to a narrator who's simultaneously the hero and villain of his own story. The album's title track pushes this duality further, with Tillman adopting the persona of a cult leader dispensing wisdom that's equal parts profound and absurd: "Now I'm learning to love the war."

The album's crown jewel, "Hollywood Forever Cemetery Sings," showcases Tillman's ability to find beauty in the grotesque. Set in the famous Los Angeles boneyard, it's ostensibly a romantic duet, but one haunted by mortality and the hollowness of modern love. The orchestration swells and recedes like waves against a shore, while Tillman's vocals dance between tenderness and detachment. It's the sound of someone falling in love while simultaneously documenting the experience for posterity – a perfect encapsulation of our selfie-obsessed era.

"Nancy From Now On" operates as the album's emotional centerpiece, a deceptively simple piano ballad that finds Tillman grappling with commitment and identity. The song's apparent sincerity is undercut by its placement within the album's broader narrative of performance and artifice, leaving listeners to wonder whether they're witnessing genuine vulnerability or another layer of the Father John Misty character.

The closing "Everyman Needs a Companion" brings the album full circle, with Tillman's voice floating over a bed of strings and piano, delivering what could be read as either genuine wisdom or elaborate joke. It's this ambiguity that makes *Fear Fun* so compelling – Tillman never lets us know where the performance ends and the person begins.

Musically, the album benefits enormously from Wilson's production, which places Tillman's vocals in a warm, analog embrace while allowing space for the orchestral arrangements to breathe. The rhythm section, anchored by Tillman's own drumming experience, provides a steady foundation for the album's more adventurous moments, while guest musicians including members of Dawes and the Shins add textural depth without overwhelming the songs' essential intimacy.

A decade on, *Fear Fun* has established itself as a pivotal release in the evolution of indie rock, pointing toward a more literate, self-aware approach to songwriting that would influence everyone from Vampire Weekend to Phoebe Bridgers. Tillman's subsequent albums may have garnered more critical acclaim and commercial success, but *Fear Fun* remains his most cohesive statement – a perfect balance of sincerity and satire that captures the peculiar anxieties of 21st-century existence.

In an era of increasing polarization, Father John Misty's greatest achievement may be his refusal to choose sides, instead occupying the uncomfortable middle ground where most of us actually live. *