The Cats

by Idrees Sulieman / John Coltrane / Kenny Burrell / Tommy Flanagan

Idrees Sulieman / John Coltrane / Kenny Burrell / Tommy Flanagan - The Cats

Ratings

Music: ★★★★☆ (4.0/5)

Sound: ☆☆☆☆☆ (0.0/5)

Review

**The Cats: A Forgotten Gem That Deserves Its Place in Jazz History**

In the sprawling landscape of 1950s jazz recordings, some sessions shine like beacons while others lurk in the shadows, waiting for rediscovery. "The Cats," recorded in 1957 for New Jazz Records, falls decidedly into the latter category—a criminally underrated hard bop session that brings together four masters at crucial points in their careers. This isn't just another blowing session; it's a snapshot of jazz evolution caught in real time.

The album emerged during a particularly fertile period for jazz, when the bebop revolution was settling into the more accessible hard bop style. Trumpeter Idrees Sulieman, though never achieving household name status, was a respected sideman who had cut his teeth with Earl Hines and Cab Calloway. By 1957, he was leading his own groups and developing a warm, lyrical trumpet voice that bridged the gap between bebop fire and cool jazz sophistication. Joining him was a young John Coltrane, still two years away from his breakthrough with "Giant Steps" but already showing signs of the harmonic adventurousness that would revolutionize jazz. Kenny Burrell brought his impeccable guitar work—clean, swinging, and melodically inventive—while Tommy Flanagan provided the kind of elegant, supportive piano work that made him one of the most in-demand accompanists of his generation.

The musical style here is quintessential hard bop: blues-inflected, rhythmically driving, but with enough harmonic sophistication to keep things interesting. What sets "The Cats" apart from countless other sessions of the era is the remarkable chemistry between the players and the quality of the material. These aren't just jazz standards getting the routine treatment; these are carefully chosen pieces that allow each musician to shine while serving the collective groove.

The standout track has to be "Minor Mishap," a Flanagan original that perfectly encapsulates the album's appeal. Sulieman's trumpet dances over the changes with a warmth that recalls Clifford Brown, while Coltrane's tenor work hints at the modal explorations to come. Burrell's guitar solo is a masterclass in melodic construction, building tension and release with surgical precision. Flanagan's comping throughout is a clinic in how to support without overwhelming, and his brief solo spots reveal a pianist with both technical command and emotional depth.

"Tommy's Tune," another Flanagan composition, showcases the group's ability to swing hard while maintaining sophisticated harmonic movement. Here, Coltrane sounds particularly inspired, his tone already developing the edge that would become his trademark. The interplay between trumpet and tenor on the head arrangements feels effortless, suggesting these musicians had found something special in the studio that day.

The album's treatment of "How Deep Is the Ocean" transforms Irving Berlin's standard into a vehicle for some of the most lyrical playing captured on the session. Sulieman's muted trumpet work is particularly effective here, demonstrating his underrated skills as a ballad interpreter. When Coltrane enters, he shows the melodic sensitivity that often gets overlooked in discussions of his later, more experimental work.

The current status of "The Cats" is somewhat bittersweet. While it has been reissued multiple times and is available digitally, it remains overshadowed by the more famous recordings in each musician's catalog. For Coltrane completists, it's essential listening that documents his development between his Miles Davis period and his emergence as a leader. Guitar aficionados rightly celebrate it as one of Burrell's finest small group outings. Jazz piano students study Flanagan's work here as an example of how to be both supportive and creative within a traditional rhythm section role.

Perhaps most importantly, "The Cats" serves as a reminder of Idrees Sulieman's considerable talents. In an era when hard bop trumpeters often favored aggression over nuance, Sulieman offered a more lyrical alternative that deserves wider recognition. His leadership on this session is subtle but effective, creating space for everyone to contribute while maintaining a cohesive group sound.

Nearly seven decades later, "The Cats" endures as a testament to the power of great musicians finding common ground. It's the kind of album that reveals new details with each listening, a perfectly crafted example of hard bop at its most refined. In a just world, it would be mentioned in the same breath as the classic Blue Note sessions of the era. Instead, it remains jazz's

Login to add to your collection and write a review.

User reviews

  • No user reviews yet.