vinylfanatics.com

In the rarefied air of contemporary experimental music, few composers navigate the liminal spaces between sound and silence with the delicate precision of Swiss composer Jürg Frey. His 2019 release "L'âme Est Sans Retenue I" stands as a masterclass in restraint, a work that demands listeners abandon their conventional relationship with musical time and embrace something altogether more contemplative and profound.

Frey, a founding member of the influential Wandelweiser collective alongside Antoine Beuger and Manfred Werder, has spent decades exploring the outer reaches of quietude. This album emerges from his ongoing fascination with what he terms "music of place" – compositions that exist not as aggressive statements but as gentle investigations into the nature of listening itself. The title, translating roughly to "The Soul Is Without Restraint," hints at the paradoxical freedom found within the composer's rigorous formal constraints.

Working within the broader tradition of reductionist composition that traces its lineage through Morton Feldman and John Cage, Frey has carved out his own distinctive territory. Where Cage embraced chance operations and Feldman luxuriated in extended duration, Frey pursues something more elusive – a kind of musical architecture built from whispers and breath, from the spaces between notes rather than the notes themselves. This is lowercase music in its purest form, demanding active, almost meditative engagement from its audience.

The album unfolds across four substantial pieces, each a careful study in temporal suspension. "Grau" opens the collection with characteristic understatement – long-held tones from clarinet and violin emerge like morning mist, occasionally punctuated by the gentle percussion of prepared piano. There's something almost devotional in the way these sounds unfold, each gesture given ample space to resonate and decay naturally. The piece doesn't so much develop as breathe, expanding and contracting according to its own mysterious logic.

"Farblos" perhaps represents the album's most successful marriage of concept and execution. Here, Frey strips away even the modest instrumental palette of the opening piece, focusing instead on the interaction between single tones and the acoustic properties of the recording space itself. The result is hypnotic – a 23-minute meditation that transforms the listener's perception of musical time. What initially appears static reveals itself as subtly dynamic, each repetition casting slightly different shadows.

The album's centrepiece, "Ohne Titel," pushes Frey's aesthetic to its logical extreme. Scored for just two instruments – a clarinet and a small percussion setup – the piece unfolds with glacial patience. Long silences punctuate brief interventions, creating a kind of musical pointillism where individual sounds take on almost sculptural weight. It's challenging music, certainly, but also deeply rewarding for those willing to surrender to its particular logic.

Closing piece "Stein" provides something approaching resolution, though in Frey's world, such concepts remain deliberately ambiguous. The interplay between sustained tones and gentle percussive textures creates moments of surprising beauty – not the overwhelming sublime of romantic tradition, but something more intimate and immediate.

The performances throughout are exemplary, with each musician demonstrating the kind of focused attention this music demands. The recording quality deserves particular praise – engineer Klaus Filip has captured not just the instruments themselves but the entire acoustic environment, allowing listeners to inhabit the same space as the performers.

This is decidedly not music for casual consumption. Frey's compositions resist the kind of passive listening that characterises much contemporary musical experience. Instead, they invite – perhaps even demand – a more active form of engagement, one that mirrors the composer's own careful attention to sonic detail.

"L'âme Est Sans Retenue I" confirms Frey's position as one of the most uncompromising voices in contemporary experimental music. While his aesthetic may seem austere, there's genuine warmth in these compositions – a humanistic quality that distinguishes his work from more conceptually rigid approaches to minimalism.

The album's influence continues to ripple through the experimental music community, inspiring younger composers to explore their own relationships with silence and space. In an era of constant sonic bombardment, Frey's gentle insistence on the value of quiet listening feels increasingly vital. This is music that doesn't merely fill time but transforms our relationship with it entirely.