vinylfanatics.com

**La Dispute - Rooms Of The House**
★★★★☆

La Dispute has never been a band content with staying in their lane, but "Rooms Of The House" finds the Grand Rapids quintet pushing furthest beyond the boundaries of what screamo and post-hardcore can contain. While 2011's "Wildlife" remains their masterpiece—a devastating exploration of death and community that elevated spoken-word hardcore to literary heights—their third full-length sees them trading some of their most explosive moments for something more intimate and, paradoxically, more universal.

The album arrives three years after "Wildlife" left fans emotionally drained and critics scrambling for adequate superlatives. That record's genius lay in its ability to transform local tragedies into something mythic, with Jordan Dreyer's impassioned storytelling weaving together tales of car crashes, overdoses, and lost love into a cohesive meditation on mortality. It was brutal, beautiful, and utterly uncompromising—the kind of album that doesn't just demand attention but commands it through sheer emotional force.

"Rooms Of The House" finds the band in a more reflective mood, though no less intense. The concept here is deceptively simple: each song represents a different room in a house, exploring the memories and emotions that spaces can hold. It's a more mature approach than their earlier work, swapping some of the raw urgency of their breakthrough for something more architecturally sound, if occasionally less immediately gripping.

Musically, La Dispute continues to defy easy categorization. While their roots remain planted in the fertile soil of Midwest emo and post-hardcore, "Rooms Of The House" sees them incorporating elements of indie rock, slowcore, and even touches of folk. The rhythm section of Adam Vass and Brad Vander Lugt provides a more restrained foundation than before, allowing space for Chad Morgan-Sterenberg and Kevin Whittemore's guitars to breathe and explore melodic territories that might have been overwhelmed by the band's earlier, more aggressive approach.

Dreyer remains the band's secret weapon, his distinctive vocal style—part sung, part spoken, part shouted—serving as the album's emotional compass. His lyrics have always been the band's calling card, and here he's crafting some of his most nuanced work. Where "Wildlife" dealt in grand gestures and sweeping narratives, "Rooms Of The House" finds poetry in the mundane, discovering profound meaning in domestic spaces and everyday interactions.

The album's strongest moments come when this new approach clicks perfectly into place. "Stay Happy There" builds from whispered confessions to cathartic release, while "Woman (Reading)" showcases the band's ability to find beauty in restraint. The title track serves as the album's emotional centerpiece, with Dreyer's narrative voice guiding listeners through a meditation on home, memory, and the weight of shared spaces. "First Reactions After Falling Through The Ice" demonstrates that the band hasn't completely abandoned their more explosive tendencies, erupting into one of their most powerful climaxes.

However, the album's more measured approach occasionally works against it. Songs like "Hudsonville MI 1956" and "Stay Happy There," while beautifully crafted, sometimes feel like they're holding back when earlier La Dispute might have pushed forward. The band's commitment to the conceptual framework occasionally constrains songs that might have benefited from more freedom to roam.

Production-wise, the album benefits from a cleaner, more spacious sound that allows each element to breathe. The band worked with producer Will Yip, whose approach emphasizes clarity without sacrificing the emotional weight that makes La Dispute so compelling. The result is their most sonically cohesive album, even if it lacks some of the raw power of their earlier work.

In the broader context of La Dispute's career, "Rooms Of The House" represents both evolution and consolidation. It's the work of a band confident enough in their abilities to pull back from the brink, to explore quieter dynamics without losing their essential intensity. While it may not reach the devastating heights of "Wildlife," it establishes La Dispute as more than just purveyors of cathartic hardcore—they're genuine artists, capable of growth and reinvention while maintaining their distinctive voice.

The album's legacy continues to grow, influencing a new generation of bands who understand that heavy music doesn't always need to be loud, and that the most powerful emotions often come wrapped in the most unexpected packages.