vinylfanatics.com

**This Old Dog**
★★★★☆

Mac DeMarco has always been something of a paradox – a slacker prince who works harder than most, a goofball who crafts songs of startling emotional depth, a gap-toothed Canadian who somehow became indie rock's most beloved weirdo. On "This Old Dog," his third proper studio album, DeMarco strips away much of the jangly guitar work that made him famous and delivers his most introspective statement yet, trading cigarettes and beer for acoustic guitars and existential dread.

The album emerged from a period of profound transition for the then-26-year-old songwriter. After years of relentless touring and living like a perpetual college freshman, DeMarco found himself grappling with the weight of growing up. His relationship with his estranged father loomed large in his thoughts, while his long-term romance with girlfriend Kiera McNally was evolving into something more serious. The result is an album that feels like a man taking stock of his life, examining the boy he was and the man he's becoming.

Musically, "This Old Dog" represents a significant departure from the warped guitar pop of "Salad Days" and "2." The electric guitars that once defined DeMarco's sound take a backseat to acoustic instruments, synthesizers, and drum machines. It's a bold move that initially feels jarring – like seeing your class clown friend suddenly wearing a suit – but the stripped-down approach serves the material beautifully. The production is intimate and lo-fi, recorded largely in DeMarco's home studio, giving the entire album the feeling of stumbling upon someone's private diary set to music.

The album's emotional centerpiece is "My Old Man," a devastating meditation on aging and the uncomfortable realization that we inevitably become our parents. Over gentle acoustic strumming and subtle synth washes, DeMarco confronts his reflection with brutal honesty: "Look in the mirror / Who do you see? / Someone familiar / But surely not me." It's the kind of universal truth that hits different at 3 AM, and DeMarco delivers it with the perfect balance of melancholy and acceptance.

"On the Level" serves as the album's mission statement, with DeMarco promising newfound maturity over a hypnotic drum machine groove. The track showcases his evolved songwriting – less concerned with clever wordplay and more focused on emotional truth. Meanwhile, "One More Love Song" offers a tender declaration of commitment that feels refreshingly sincere coming from someone who built his reputation on ironic detachment.

The title track finds DeMarco at his most vulnerable, using the metaphor of an aging dog to explore themes of loyalty, time, and unconditional love. It's a simple song that reveals new layers with each listen, much like the album itself. "Dreams from Yesterday" closes the record with a wistful look backward, its dreamy synthesizers and philosophical lyrics providing a perfect bookend to this chapter of DeMarco's artistic evolution.

Not every experiment lands perfectly. Some tracks feel undercooked, and longtime fans might miss the guitar heroics that made songs like "Freaking Out the Neighborhood" so immediately grabbing. The drum machine-heavy arrangements occasionally feel too sterile for an artist whose charm has always been his human imperfections. But these are minor quibbles with an album that succeeds brilliantly at its primary goal: showing us a more mature, contemplative Mac DeMarco without sacrificing the essential weirdness that makes him special.

Five years later, "This Old Dog" stands as a crucial pivot point in DeMarco's discography. It proved he could evolve beyond the slacker persona without losing his core audience, paving the way for subsequent experiments like "Here Comes the Cowboy." More importantly, it established him as a songwriter capable of real emotional depth, someone who could make you laugh and break your heart in the same three-minute song.

In an era of manufactured authenticity and algorithmic playlists, Mac DeMarco remains defiantly human – messy, contradictory, and utterly genuine. "This Old Dog" captures an artist in transition, growing up in public while maintaining the essential spark that made us fall in love with him in the first place. It's the sound of someone learning that maturity doesn't mean abandoning your inner weirdo; it means figuring out when to let him out to play.