vinylfanatics.com

**Nada Surf - Let Go**
★★★★☆

By the time Nada Surf entered the studio to record "Let Go" in 2002, they had already experienced the brutal whiplash of music industry fickleness. The New York trio had tasted fleeting fame with their 1996 alt-rock anthem "Popular" – a deliciously sarcastic deconstruction of teenage social hierarchies that became an MTV staple – only to watch their major label career implode when Elektra Records unceremoniously dropped them in 1998. For many bands, this would have been the end of the story. Instead, Matthew Caws, Daniel Lorca, and Ira Elliot used their exile as an opportunity to rediscover what made them tick as musicians.

The years between major label purgatory and "Let Go" weren't wasted. The band retreated to their roots, playing smaller venues, reconnecting with their fanbase, and most importantly, allowing their songwriting to mature beyond the clever-but-shallow territory that had defined their earlier work. When they finally emerged with "Let Go," it was clear that getting kicked off the major label treadmill was the best thing that could have happened to them.

Gone was the bratty snark of "High/Low," replaced by something far more compelling: genuine emotional depth wrapped in immaculately crafted indie pop. "Let Go" finds Nada Surf operating in a sweet spot between the jangly guitar work of R.E.M., the melodic sensibilities of Teenage Fanclub, and the introspective lyricism of Belle and Sebastian. Caws' voice, always the band's secret weapon, had developed a weathered warmth that perfectly complemented his increasingly sophisticated songwriting.

The album opens with "Blizzard of '77," a perfect mission statement that showcases everything great about this new iteration of Nada Surf. Built around a hypnotic guitar riff and Caws' conversational vocals, it's both musically sophisticated and emotionally direct. The song's nostalgic meditation on childhood memories and the passage of time sets the tone for an album that consistently finds profundity in life's smaller moments.

"Inside of Love" ranks among the finest songs in the Nada Surf catalog, a gorgeous slow-burn that builds from whispered intimacy to soaring catharsis. Caws' exploration of romantic vulnerability feels lived-in rather than performed, while the band's restraint – knowing exactly when to pull back and when to surge forward – demonstrates a maturity that was only hinted at in their earlier work. Similarly stunning is "Hi-Speed Soul," which marries a driving rhythm section to one of Caws' most emotionally naked vocal performances.

The album's secret weapon might be "Happy Kid," a deceptively simple song that captures the bittersweet nature of growing up with remarkable economy. Over a bed of chiming guitars and subtle percussion, Caws reflects on the gap between childhood dreams and adult realities without falling into either cynicism or false nostalgia. It's the kind of song that reveals new layers with each listen, a quality that defines "Let Go" as a whole.

Even when Nada Surf rocks harder, as on the driving "Fruit Fly" or the urgent "Neither Heaven Nor Space," they maintain the emotional intelligence that separates "Let Go" from typical indie rock fare. These aren't songs designed to soundtrack your weekend; they're carefully constructed emotional statements that happen to come wrapped in irresistible melodies.

The production, handled by the band along with Louie Lino, strikes the perfect balance between polish and intimacy. Every instrument sits exactly where it should in the mix, creating space for both the band's instrumental interplay and Caws' increasingly confident vocals. There's a lived-in quality to the sound that makes "Let Go" feel like a conversation with old friends rather than a performance.

Twenty years later, "Let Go" stands as both Nada Surf's creative peak and a testament to the power of artistic perseverance. The album's influence can be heard in countless indie pop acts who've followed, but more importantly, it proved that sometimes the best thing that can happen to a band is losing everything and starting over. In an era of manufactured authenticity, "Let Go" remains a masterclass in how to transform personal setbacks into transcendent art. It's the sound of a band finally becoming themselves.