vinylfanatics.com

**Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea**
*★★★★★*

There's a moment halfway through "Good Fortune" where Polly Jean Harvey sounds almost... happy. It's jarring, frankly. This is the same artist who once howled about 50-foot queenies and dry counties, who made guitars sound like they were being tortured in medieval dungeons. But here she is in 2000, practically purring over a groove that wouldn't sound out of place on a Radiohead album, singing about love like she actually believes in it. What the hell happened to PJ Harvey?

The answer, it turns out, is New York City. After nearly a decade of mining the darkest corners of rural England and her own psyche, Harvey packed her bags for Manhattan, fell head-over-heels for a certain Queens-born musician (that'd be Vincent Gallo, though she's never confirmed it), and discovered that sometimes the best way to reinvent yourself is to fall completely, stupidly in love while surrounded by eight million strangers.

*Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea* finds Harvey at her most accessible, but don't mistake accessible for compromised. Working with producers Rob Ellis and Flood, she's crafted an album that feels both deeply personal and cinematically vast, like she's soundtracking her own romantic comedy while simultaneously scoring a David Lynch film. It's a neat trick, and one that only an artist of Harvey's caliber could pull off.

The album opens with "Big Exit," a swaggering piece of garage rock that announces Harvey's new persona with all the subtlety of a Times Square billboard. Over a riff that could've been stolen from The White Stripes (if they'd existed yet), she declares herself "the catalyst" with the kind of confidence that makes you believe her. It's followed by "Good Fortune," where Harvey trades her usual gothic wails for something approaching actual melody, backed by strings that shimmer like heat waves off summer pavement.

But the real revelation here is "A Place Called Home," a duet with Radiohead's Thom Yorke that captures the disorientation of finding yourself in a new city, a new relationship, a new version of yourself. Yorke's falsetto weaves around Harvey's increasingly confident vocals like smoke, creating something that's both ethereally beautiful and oddly unsettling. It's the sound of two outsiders finding temporary shelter in each other's company.

The album's centerpiece, "The Whores Hustle and the Hustlers Whore," sees Harvey channeling her inner Lou Reed over a hypnotic bass line that could soundtrack a late-night subway ride through the city's underbelly. It's classic Harvey—dark, provocative, slightly dangerous—but filtered through her new metropolitan lens. She's still the keen observer of human nature she's always been, but now she's got eight million new subjects to study.

Not everything works perfectly. "You Said Something" veers dangerously close to adult contemporary territory, and "Kamikaze" feels like Harvey trying on different personas without fully committing to any of them. But these are minor quibbles with an album that represents a major artistic breakthrough.

The real triumph of *Stories From The City* is how Harvey manages to expand her sonic palette without losing her essential weirdness. "We Float" builds from a whispered confession into a full-blown anthem, complete with gospel-tinged backing vocals and a guitar solo that sounds like it's reaching for the heavens. "This Is Love" finds her at her most vulnerable, admitting "I can't believe life's so complex" over delicate piano and strings that seem to cradle her voice.

The album's legacy has only grown stronger with time. It won the 2001 Mercury Prize, making Harvey the first woman to receive the honor, and it's increasingly cited as a crucial bridge between '90s alternative rock and the more experimental sounds that would dominate the following decade. More importantly, it proved that Harvey could reinvent herself completely while remaining unmistakably herself—a lesson that countless artists have tried and failed to learn.

Twenty-plus years later, *Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea* stands as Harvey's most cohesive statement, a love letter to transformation written by an artist brave enough to let herself be changed by experience. It's the sound of someone discovering that sometimes the best stories come from stepping outside your comfort zone and seeing what happens. In Harvey's case, what happened was magic.