vinylfanatics.com

When R.E.M. decamped to Reflection Sound Studios in Charlotte, North Carolina, in early 1984, they were a band at a crossroads. Their debut *Murmur* had earned critical hosannas and college radio devotion, but commercial success remained tantalizingly out of reach. The Athens quartet—Michael Stipe's cryptic mumble, Peter Buck's jangly guitar archaeology, Mike Mills' melodic bass counterpoint, and Bill Berry's propulsive drumming—needed to prove they weren't just critical darlings destined for cult status.

*Reckoning* emerged from those sessions as both vindication and evolution, a record that refined their mysterious Southern gothic into something approaching accessibility without sacrificing an ounce of their enigmatic charm. Working again with producer Mitch Easter and engineer Don Dixon, the band crafted their most cohesive statement yet, one that would cement their position as America's most vital alternative rock band.

The album opens with "Harborcoat," a swirling meditation that immediately establishes the record's more confident tone. Stipe's vocals, while still deliciously oblique, feel more purposeful here, his stream-of-consciousness imagery coalescing into something resembling narrative. Buck's guitar work throughout is a masterclass in restraint and texture, weaving folk-rock traditions through a post-punk sensibility that feels uniquely American.

It's on "7 Chinese Bros." that the band's growing songcraft becomes undeniable. Built around one of Buck's most infectious riffs, the track showcases Mills' increasingly sophisticated bass playing while Berry locks into a groove that's both driving and subtle. Stipe delivers lines like "This monkey's gone to heaven" with a conviction that makes the surreal feel profound, a trick that would become central to R.E.M.'s appeal.

The album's emotional centerpiece, "So. Central Rain (I'm Sorry)," stands as perhaps the band's first truly great song. Here, Stipe's apology—reportedly to former manager Jefferson Holt—cuts through his usual lyrical fog with startling clarity. "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry," he repeats, and for once, the meaning feels unambiguous. Buck's arpeggiated guitar line dances around Mills' melodic bass, creating a musical conversation that mirrors the song's themes of regret and reconciliation.

"Pretty Persuasion" finds the band at their most propulsive, Berry's drumming pushing the song forward while Buck layers guitars with increasing intensity. It's R.E.M. at their most rock-oriented, yet the song never abandons their commitment to melody and atmosphere. The track would become a live favorite, its energy translating perfectly to their increasingly powerful stage performances.

The album's most haunting moment comes with "Camera," a slow-burning exploration of voyeurism and observation that showcases the band's ability to create tension through space and dynamics. Stipe's vocals float over a sparse arrangement, each instrument given room to breathe and contribute to the song's unsettling atmosphere.

*Reckoning* benefits enormously from the band's decision to record quickly and live in the studio. The performances feel spontaneous and lived-in, capturing the chemistry that made R.E.M.'s live shows so compelling. Easter and Dixon's production strikes the perfect balance between clarity and mystery, allowing each instrument to be heard while maintaining the dreamlike quality that defined the band's aesthetic.

The album's sequencing deserves particular praise, with each song flowing naturally into the next while maintaining distinct identities. From the driving momentum of "Second Guessing" to the pastoral beauty of "Time After Time (AnnElise)," the record takes listeners on a journey through R.E.M.'s expanding musical landscape.

*Reckoning* would prove to be R.E.M.'s commercial breakthrough, reaching number 27 on the Billboard 200 and establishing them as MTV favorites. More importantly, it demonstrated that the band could grow and evolve without compromising their artistic vision. The album's influence on alternative rock cannot be overstated—countless bands would attempt to capture R.E.M.'s combination of accessibility and mystery, though few would manage it with such grace.

Nearly four decades later, *Reckoning* stands as both a perfect snapshot of R.E.M. at their hungriest and a blueprint for intelligent alternative rock. It's an album that rewards both casual listening and deep analysis, revealing new layers with each encounter. In capturing a band discovering their power while maintaining their mystery,