vinylfanatics.com

**Taking Back Sunday - Where You Want To Be**
★★★★☆

In the sweltering summer of 2004, when emo was crawling out of basement shows and into the fluorescent-lit aisles of Hot Topic, Taking Back Sunday delivered their most ambitious statement yet. "Where You Want To Be" arrived like a perfectly timed haymaker to the gut of anyone who thought they'd outgrown the dramatic theatrics of suburban heartbreak. This wasn't just another collection of songs about ex-girlfriends and feelings – it was a full-scale emotional assault wrapped in the kind of production sheen that major labels dream about.

The Long Island quintet had already made waves with 2002's "Tell All Your Friends," a scrappy debut that helped define the sound of early 2000s emo alongside Dashboard Confessional and Brand New. But that album's DIY charm came with growing pains, lineup changes, and the kind of interpersonal drama that would make a soap opera writer blush. Guitarist John Nolan and bassist Shaun Cooper had jumped ship to form Straylight Run, leaving frontman Adam Lazzara and guitarist Eddie Reyes to rebuild from the ashes. Enter Fred Mascherino and Matt Rubano, two fresh faces ready to help Taking Back Sunday evolve from scrappy underdogs into arena-ready contenders.

Working with producer Eric Rachel, the band crafted a sonic palette that maintained their emotional intensity while adding layers of polish that their previous work had lacked. The guitars bite harder, the rhythms punch deeper, and Lazzara's vocals – still delivered with his signature microphone-swinging theatrics – cut through the mix with newfound clarity. This is emo with muscles, post-hardcore with a heart, and pop-punk with actual stakes.

"A Decade Under the Influence" opens the album like a mission statement, its driving rhythm and anthemic chorus serving notice that Taking Back Sunday 2.0 means business. Lazzara's vocals alternate between vulnerable whispers and full-throated screams, while the dual guitar attack creates a wall of sound that's both crushing and cathartic. It's the kind of song that transforms teenagers into believers and turns casual listeners into devotees.

But the album's secret weapon is "MakeDamnSure," a track that perfectly encapsulates everything that made mid-2000s emo so irresistible. Built around a hypnotic guitar riff and propelled by one of the most memorable choruses of the decade, it's three and a half minutes of pure emotional manipulation – and it works every single time. The song's success on radio and MTV helped push the album to gold status, proving that vulnerability could be commercially viable when wrapped in the right package.

"This Photograph Is Proof (I Know You Know)" showcases the band's ability to balance aggression with melody, while "Number Five With a Bullet" delivers the kind of bitter kiss-off that made Taking Back Sunday essential listening for anyone navigating the wreckage of young love. Mascherino's guitar work throughout is particularly impressive, adding technical proficiency without sacrificing the emotional directness that made the band's earlier work so compelling.

The album isn't without its missteps – some tracks feel overstuffed with ideas, and the production occasionally threatens to smother the raw emotion that should be front and center. But these are minor quibbles with a record that largely succeeds in its ambitious goals.

"Where You Want To Be" arrived at the perfect cultural moment, when emo was transitioning from underground movement to mainstream phenomenon. The album helped bridge that gap, maintaining enough credibility to satisfy longtime fans while offering enough accessibility to win over newcomers. It's a record that sounds equally at home blasting from a teenager's bedroom stereo or echoing through an amphitheater filled with thousands of voices singing along.

Nearly two decades later, "Where You Want To Be" stands as both a time capsule of mid-2000s alternative rock and a testament to Taking Back Sunday's ability to evolve without losing their core identity. While the band has continued releasing albums and touring regularly – recently celebrating the 20th anniversary of "Tell All Your Friends" with extensive touring – this sophomore effort remains their commercial and creative peak. It's the sound of a band discovering they could be bigger than their wildest dreams while somehow managing not to lose their souls in the process. In a genre often dismissed as juvenile or dispositive, Taking Back Sunday proved that growing up doesn't have to mean growing boring.