vinylfanatics.com

**The Left Banke: Baroque Pop's Beautiful Tragedy**

In the annals of 1960s pop music, few bands burned as brightly and briefly as The Left Banke, the New York quintet who practically invented baroque pop before imploding in a haze of teenage drama and creative differences. Their story reads like a cautionary tale written by Nick Hornby – equal parts musical genius and interpersonal catastrophe, with a soundtrack that still sounds impossibly elegant nearly six decades later.

The band's origins trace back to teenage songwriter Michael Brown, a classically trained prodigy who had the audacity to drag harpsichords and string arrangements into the world of three-chord rock. Working with lyricist Tony Sansone, Brown crafted ornate pop confections that sounded like The Beatles had been raised on Bach instead of Chuck Berry. When these compositions found their voice through the angelic vocals of Steve Martin Caro (not the comedian, thankfully), something magical happened – though "magical" might be understating it.

Their 1966 masterpiece "Walk Away Renée" didn't just climb the charts; it redefined what pop music could be. Built around a hypnotic harpsichord line and lush string arrangement, the song was baroque pop's birth certificate, inspiring everyone from The Beach Boys to The Zombies to incorporate classical elements into their sound. The track's melancholy sophistication – allegedly inspired by Brown's unrequited crush on bassist Tom Finn's girlfriend Renée Fladen-Kamm – proved that teenage heartbreak could produce art as refined as anything coming out of Tin Pan Alley.

**Walk Away Renée / Pretty Ballerina (1967)** served as their stunning debut, a collection that feels like chamber music for the AM radio generation. Beyond the title tracks – both chart-topping gems that showcase the band's gift for combining classical instrumentation with irresistible pop hooks – the album reveals remarkable depth. "She May Call You Up Tonight" demonstrates their ability to craft perfect three-minute symphonies, while "I Haven't Got the Nerve" strips away the orchestration to reveal the raw emotion beneath their baroque facade. The production, handled by the band themselves along with engineer Brooks Arthur, captures every delicate detail without sacrificing the songs' emotional punch.

Unfortunately, success couldn't mask the band's internal combustion. Brown's perfectionist tendencies clashed with the other members' desire for creative input, leading to his departure just as they were hitting their commercial peak. **The Left Banke Too (1968)** attempted to continue without their primary songwriter, and while tracks like "Desiree" and "Goodbye Holly" maintain the band's sophisticated approach, the album lacks the cohesive vision that made their debut so compelling. It's the sound of talented musicians trying to replicate lightning in a bottle – admirable, but ultimately futile.

The final chapter came with **Strangers on a Train (1986)**, an unlikely reunion album that found the surviving members attempting to recapture their 1960s magic in the Reagan era. While the album contains moments of genuine beauty – particularly the title track and "Queen of Paradise" – it feels more like a nostalgic footnote than a genuine artistic statement. The baroque pop sound that once seemed revolutionary now carried the weight of nostalgia, making the album feel like a museum piece rather than a living, breathing work of art.

The Left Banke's legacy extends far beyond their brief commercial success. Their influence can be heard in everything from The Moody Blues' symphonic rock to Belle and Sebastian's indie pop orchestrations. Modern artists like Vampire Weekend and The Divine Comedy owe a clear debt to Brown's vision of pop music as high art, while the recent baroque pop revival has introduced their songs to new generations of listeners who recognize their timeless appeal.

Today, "Walk Away Renée" and "Pretty Ballerina" remain perfect pop artifacts, songs that capture both the innocence and sophistication of their era while transcending it entirely. The Left Banke proved that complexity and accessibility weren't mutually exclusive – a lesson that countless musicians are still trying to learn. Their brief, brilliant career stands as proof that sometimes the most beautiful music comes from the most dysfunctional circumstances, and that teenage emotions, when filtered through genuine artistry, can produce something approaching the sublime.