vinylfanatics.com

After the sonic bombast and stadium-sized anthems that defined their 2000s output, U2 found themselves at a curious crossroads in 2009. "No Line on the Horizon" arrived as their twelfth studio album, promising a return to experimental territory that hadn't been fully explored since the Berlin trilogy of the '90s. What emerged was their most polarizing release in years – a fascinating, flawed beast that simultaneously reached for the stars while occasionally stumbling over its own ambitious feet.

The album's genesis traces back to 2006, when the Dublin quartet retreated to Morocco with producers Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois, seeking inspiration in the exotic soundscapes of Fez. The sessions were reportedly loose and exploratory, with the band jamming extensively and allowing songs to develop organically. This North African sojourn was followed by additional recording in Dublin and New York, creating a patchwork of influences that would define the album's restless, searching character.

Musically, "No Line on the Horizon" represents U2's most adventurous sonic palette since "Zooropa." The opening title track immediately signals this intent, with Larry Mullen Jr.'s tribal drumming and Adam Clayton's hypnotic bassline creating a foundation that's both primal and futuristic. Bono's vocals soar over layers of treated guitars and ambient textures, setting a tone that's more introspective than the chest-beating declarations of recent efforts. It's U2 as sonic explorers rather than conquering heroes.

The album's greatest triumph is "Moment of Surrender," a seven-minute epic that ranks among the band's finest compositions. Built around a simple piano figure, the song gradually accumulates layers of instrumentation while Bono delivers one of his most vulnerable vocal performances. The lyrics, dealing with spiritual crisis and redemption, feel genuinely personal rather than grandiose. It's the kind of song that reminds you why U2 became important in the first place – their ability to make the personal universal and the spiritual tangible.

"Magnificent" attempts to recapture the anthemic glory of their Joshua Tree era, and largely succeeds through sheer force of will. The Edge's guitar work shimmers and cascades, while the rhythm section locks into a groove that's both driving and spacious. It's stadium rock, but stadium rock with nuance and emotional weight. Similarly, "I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight" manages to be both radio-friendly and artistically satisfying, its infectious energy masking surprisingly complex arrangements.

The album's experimental impulses reach their peak with "Fez – Being Born," a sprawling, largely instrumental piece that sounds like Pink Floyd jamming in a Moroccan marketplace. It's either self-indulgent noodling or a transcendent piece of ambient rock, depending on your tolerance for U2's more esoteric tendencies. The track divides listeners as sharply as anything in their catalog.

Less successful are attempts to recapture past glories through formula rather than inspiration. "Get On Your Boots" sounds like a calculated attempt at creating a "Vertigo"-style rocker, but lacks that song's primal urgency. The lyrics veer into self-parody territory, and even The Edge's reliable guitar wizardry can't salvage the track's fundamental hollowness.

"White as Snow" and "Breathe" showcase the band's quieter, more contemplative side, with mixed results. The former succeeds through its stark beauty and Bono's restrained delivery, while the latter feels like a missed opportunity, its promising atmospheric beginning never quite coalescing into a memorable song.

The album's legacy remains complicated more than a decade after its release. Commercially, it performed respectably but failed to match the massive success of "How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb." Critically, it was praised for its ambition while being criticized for its inconsistency. In the context of U2's catalog, it stands as their last truly adventurous statement, a final attempt to push boundaries before settling into the comfortable nostalgia of "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience."

"No Line on the Horizon" ultimately feels like a transitional album – the sound of a band caught between their experimental instincts and their stadium-rock identity. When it works, as on "Moment of Surrender" and the title track, it suggests alternate paths U2 might have taken. When it doesn't, it serves as a reminder that even the most successful bands can lose their way. It's a fl