vinylfanatics.com

In the pantheon of spectacular rock and roll miscalculations, U2's ninth studio album Pop stands as a fascinating monument to ambition colliding headfirst with reality. Released in March 1997, this kaleidoscopic fever dream of an album found the world's biggest rock band attempting to reinvent themselves as cyberpunk disco evangelists, complete with mirror ball halos and enough electronic wizardry to power a small rave.

The seeds of Pop were planted in the fertile creative soil of U2's mid-'90s renaissance. Following the critical triumph of Achtung Baby and the theatrical excess of Zooropa, Bono, Edge, Adam Clayton, and Larry Mullen Jr. found themselves creatively restless in their newly adopted personas as ironic rock stars. The band had successfully shed their earnest '80s skin, but the question remained: what next? The answer, it seemed, lay in the pulsating heart of electronic dance music that was dominating clubs from Ibiza to Manchester.

Working primarily at their Dublin studio, Hanover Quay, U2 enlisted a small army of collaborators including Flood, Howie B, and Steve Osborne to help them navigate the brave new world of drum machines, samplers, and sequencers. The result was their most sonically adventurous album to date – a shape-shifting beast that borrowed liberally from techno, trip-hop, and ambient house while still maintaining the band's core DNA of soaring melodies and spiritual yearning.

Pop opens with "Discotheque," a strutting, bass-heavy anthem that sounds like U2 covering themselves through a kaleidoscope of disco balls and strobe lights. It's simultaneously their most danceable moment and their most overtly commercial, a contradiction that runs through the album's entire 60-minute runtime. The track's infectious groove masks typically oblique Bono lyrics about faith and desire, proving that even when embracing the dancefloor, U2 couldn't entirely abandon their role as rock's most earnest philosophers.

The album's true masterpiece arrives with "Staring at the Sun," a gorgeous meditation on mortality wrapped in shimmering electronics and Edge's most inventive guitar work since "Where the Streets Have No Name." Here, the marriage between organic and synthetic elements feels effortless, with Bono's vulnerable vocals floating over a bed of programmed beats and analog warmth. It's U2 at their most human precisely when they're at their most mechanical.

"Last Night on Earth" captures the millennial anxiety that was beginning to permeate popular culture, its apocalyptic imagery underscored by a relentless electronic pulse that suggests both celebration and dread. Meanwhile, "Please" finds the band tackling the Northern Ireland troubles with characteristic directness, though the song's stuttering rhythms and fractured structure mirror the complexity of the subject matter.

The album's most successful fusion of old and new arrives with "If God Will Send His Angels," a track that manages to sound both futuristic and timeless. Bono's plea for divine intervention is set against a backdrop of subtle electronics and Edge's chiming guitar, creating something that feels genuinely transcendent rather than merely technological.

Yet Pop is not without its flaws. At 14 tracks, it's an occasionally exhausting listen, with some experiments feeling more like exercises than fully realized songs. "Miami" and "The Playboy Mansion" showcase the band's newfound fascination with American excess, but lack the emotional weight that makes U2's best work so compelling. The album suffers from what might be called "option anxiety" – too many sonic possibilities leading to occasional indecision.

The album's commercial reception was mixed, peaking at number one in numerous countries but failing to match the sustained success of its predecessors. The accompanying PopMart tour, with its 40-foot lemon-shaped disco ball and supermarket-themed staging, was initially met with bewilderment before eventually being recognized as one of the band's most innovative live experiences.

Today, Pop stands as U2's great "what if" album – a bold creative statement that arrived perhaps too early for widespread acceptance. In an era where the boundaries between rock and electronic music have largely dissolved, Pop sounds remarkably prescient. Songs like "Mofo" and "Gone" feel less like experiments and more like successful transmissions from a parallel universe where U2 became the world's biggest electronic rock band.

Pop may not be U2's most consistent album, but it remains their most fearless – a testament to a band willing to risk everything in pursuit of something