vinylfanatics.com

**U2 - Rattle And Hum**
★★★☆☆

In the annals of rock hubris, few albums arrive with as much fanfare and leave with as much controversy as U2's 1988 double opus, *Rattle And Hum*. Coming hot on the heels of *The Joshua Tree*, which had catapulted the Dublin quartet from stadium-fillers to genuine cultural phenomenon, this sprawling hybrid of live recordings and studio experimentation represents both the peak of U2's imperial phase and the moment when their earnest ambitions finally outstripped their grasp.

The genesis of *Rattle And Hum* lay in U2's intoxication with America – not the Reagan-era superpower they'd critiqued on *The Joshua Tree*, but the mythical heartland of blues, gospel, and rock'n'roll that had shaped their musical DNA. Fresh from conquering the world's biggest stages, Bono, Edge, Adam Clayton, and Larry Mullen Jr. embarked on what amounted to a musical pilgrimage, seeking to commune with their heroes and plant their flag in the pantheon of American music. The accompanying Phil Joanou documentary captured this journey in all its black-and-white, sepia-tinted glory – and pretension.

Musically, *Rattle And Hum* finds U2 stretching far beyond their established template of anthemic rock. The album lurches between thunderous live recordings that showcase the band's unparalleled ability to move mountains of people, and studio experiments that see them dabbling in blues, gospel, folk, and country. It's an ambitious stylistic potpourri that sometimes works brilliantly and occasionally falls flat on its face.

The album's undeniable peak arrives early with "Desire," a swaggering Bo Diddley-influenced rocker that marries primitive rhythm with Edge's most infectious guitar work. It's U2 at their most primal and effective – proof that sometimes the best way forward is backward. "Angel Of Harlem," meanwhile, finds the band channeling their inner Stax Records, complete with horn section and Bono's most soulful vocal performance. When it works, it's joyous; when it doesn't, it feels like musical tourism.

The live tracks capture U2 at their imperial best. "Where The Streets Have No Name" from their legendary Red Rocks show remains one of rock's great transcendent moments, while "Sunday Bloody Sunday" crackles with political urgency. "Bad," stretched to epic proportions, demonstrates how U2 could transform three chords into something approaching religious experience. These performances remind you why U2 became the biggest band in the world – they didn't just play songs, they created communal experiences.

However, the album's reach often exceeds its grasp. "Heartland" meanders through six minutes of ponderous Americana pastiche, while "God Part II" – a response to John Lennon's "God" – feels like exactly the kind of presumptuous gesture that would fuel the backlash against the band. Most egregiously, collaborations with legends like B.B. King ("When Love Comes To Town") and Bob Dylan ("Love Rescue Me") feel stilted and reverential rather than inspired.

The album's fatal flaw lies in its naked ambition. Where *The Joshua Tree* had channeled U2's spiritual and political concerns into focused, powerful statements, *Rattle And Hum* feels like a band drunk on their own importance, desperate to prove they belonged alongside their heroes rather than simply being themselves. The accompanying film's grandiose imagery – Bono genuflecting before a Harlem gospel choir, the band posing in Monument Valley – crystallized a growing perception that U2 had disappeared up their own mythology.

Yet time has been kinder to *Rattle And Hum* than its initial reception suggested. Stripped of its pompous context, songs like "All I Want Is You" reveal themselves as genuinely beautiful, showcasing U2's gift for emotional directness. The album's documentary impulse, capturing a specific moment when rock stars could still believably position themselves as seekers and students, now feels quaint rather than irritating.

*Rattle And Hum* remains U2's most divisive album – a fascinating failure that contains some of their finest moments alongside their most misguided. It's the sound of a great band overreaching magnificently, and while the crash that followed (*Achtung Baby