vinylfanatics.com

**XTC - Nonsuch**
★★★★☆

By 1992, XTC had already endured more drama than most bands experience in several lifetimes. The Swindon art-pop perfectionists had been grounded since 1982 when Andy Partridge's stage fright brought their touring days to an abrupt halt, transforming them from a kinetic live act into meticulous studio craftsmen. Following the creative peak of *Skylarking* and the commercial disappointment of *Oranges & Lemons*, the band found themselves in familiar territory: critically adored yet commercially overlooked, with Partridge and Colin Moulding's songwriting partnership firing on all cylinders despite the industry's apparent indifference.

Enter *Nonsuch*, XTC's most ambitious and arguably most successful attempt at bridging their experimental tendencies with mainstream accessibility. Recorded during a period when the band had finally wrested creative control from their management and secured a more favorable record deal, the album finds Partridge and Moulding in peak form, crafting what amounts to a love letter to the entire history of British pop music while simultaneously pushing their own sound into uncharted territories.

The album opens with "The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead," a deceptively simple piece of acoustic-driven pop that masks a biting commentary on celebrity culture and messianic complexes. It's vintage XTC: immediately catchy yet lyrically subversive, with Partridge's vocals dancing over a arrangement that recalls both The Beatles' pastoral period and the band's own knack for unexpected harmonic turns. The song's success as a minor radio hit proved that XTC could still craft undeniable hooks when they set their minds to it.

*Nonsuch* reveals its true genius in its remarkable stylistic diversity. "My Bird Performs" is a swirling psychedelic confection that wouldn't sound out of place on *Sgt. Pepper's*, complete with backwards vocals and a melody that seems to float rather than walk. Meanwhile, "Dear Madam Barnum" channels music hall traditions through XTC's art-rock filter, creating something that's simultaneously nostalgic and utterly contemporary. The album's sonic palette is vast, incorporating everything from Indian instruments to orchestral arrangements, yet it never feels scattered or unfocused.

Colin Moulding's contributions prove equally essential, with "The Ugly Underneath" serving as a perfect counterpoint to Partridge's more ornate compositions. Moulding's bass-driven rocker strips away the baroque flourishes to reveal the band's punk roots, while his tender "Bungalow" offers one of the album's most emotionally direct moments. The interplay between Partridge's cerebral wordplay and Moulding's more intuitive approach gives *Nonsuch* a dynamic tension that prevents it from becoming too precious or overly intellectual.

The album's secret weapon might be "The Disappointed," a sprawling epic that builds from a simple piano figure into a full-blown orchestral statement. It's XTC at their most cinematic, with Partridge's vocals soaring over arrangements that shift and evolve like a film score. The song perfectly encapsulates the album's central theme of disillusionment tempered by hope, a subject the band had been exploring since their earliest days but never with such nuanced sophistication.

Producer Gus Dudgeon, fresh from his work with Elton John, deserves significant credit for helping XTC achieve their most polished sound without sacrificing their essential quirkiness. The production is warm and detailed, allowing space for every instrumental flourish while maintaining the punch necessary for the band's more aggressive moments.

*Nonsuch* stands as XTC's most complete artistic statement, a 17-track journey through the group's collective musical obsessions that never outstays its welcome. While it failed to achieve the commercial breakthrough the band desperately needed, its influence can be heard in countless indie and alternative acts who followed. The album's sophisticated pop craftsmanship and willingness to experiment within traditional song structures helped establish a template that bands like Radiohead, Blur, and countless others would later explore.

Today, *Nonsuch* is rightfully regarded as XTC's masterpiece, a album that captures a band at the absolute peak of their creative powers. It's a record that rewards both casual listening and deep analysis, revealing new details with each encounter while never losing its essential humanity. In a just world, *Nonsuch* would be mentioned alongside *Pet Sounds* and *Abbey Road* as